【Jane Huang accused Dzongsar Khyentse Rinpoche】

 The communication data between Jane Huang and Dzongsar Khyentse Rinpoche are from Jane Huang's blog & Facebook, which are all her own words.

Allegations 1.

Jane Huang claimed that she had accused Dzongsar Rinpoche of pimping her to know Karmapa, and Dzongsar Rinpoche answered "Yes."

Clarification:

According to Mirror Weekly, this conversation took place on May 14, 2016.  The day before (5/13), Dzongsar Rinpoche posted a photo of his "Hema Hema" movie with actress Zhou Xun on his public Facebook, and the post jokingly wrote, "Pimping now?".  And Jane Huang asked, "Rinpoche, you are pimp" the next day and got a "yes" answer, which is Rinpoche's follow-up remarks on this post.

Allegation 2.

『Jane Huang: "She questioned whether Dzongsar Khyentse was still helping Karmapa pimps and thought that such behavior was very shameful, and the other party replied " ho ho ".』—Mirror Weekly

Evidence:

The following is the record of the text message between Jane Huang and Dzongsar Khyentse Rinpoche on May 6, 2018. 

『H: Rinpoche you're so irresponsible. Still pimping for Karmapa? Shame on you 

Rinpoche: Ho Ho 

Rinpoche: Where have u been 

Rinpoche: What did I do now

Rinpoche: I don't even have his contact 

Rinpoche: Last time I talked was when he came to Bir

H: Stop being a smart mouth 

Rinpoche: Ok 

H: Why don't you found a workshop for the girls that are going to serve "lamas? Like a female leadership workshop? 

H: Don't abuse the word" romantic』-Jane Huang’s Facebook 

Analysis:

1.    The H took the initiative to call Rinpoche on May 6, 2018, and there was no reason to accuse Rinpoche of pimping for Karmapa.  According to the content of this call, Rinpoche and Jane Huang had not been in contact for some time, so Jane Huang accused Rinpoche, and Rinpoche was confused.

2.    Jane Huang only intercepted the "ho ho" of Rinpoche's reply, accusing him of confessing to helping Karmapa Pimp.  Then she said that Rinpoche should set up a female workshop to "serve" the Lama.

3.    It is evident that the H has set a trap in advance, deliberately slandering Rinpoche. 

Allegation 3.

「"Dzongsar Khyentse Rinpoche asks Jane Huang to help pass on his religious ideas to Karmapa."

 "Jane Huang: Dzongsar Khyentse Rinpoche is deliberately trying to change you. He is doing everything he can, and he wants to change you, Karmapa."」-Mirror Weekly

Evidence:

 According to the contents of the call between Jane Huang and Rinpoche on November 20, 2016, it contradicted the statement of Mirror Weekly.        

『Rinpoche: I have nothing 

Rinpoche: He has so much work

H: You don't know K's brain has very little new things 

Rinpoche: What do I do 

H: Your institute, KF, Siddhartha festival, movie, teachings, drupchen, everything 

H: And he visited deer park only for 20min?  

H: Yeah he is almighty but his activities are not relevant to modern people

Rinpoche: Why not 

H: You see he is so too used to / enjoyed all this setting up of sister and securities 

H: And his speech, I don't understand Tibetan but I bet he said all those things he is suppose to say right? 

H: Anyway he must feel good when he saw you being so humble. But he should really learn from you 

H: Even the old Labrang !!

Rinpoche: Am not humble

Rinpoche: I just bent down 

H: Haha That's what he needs and want He is so young, mentally, almost childish 

H: So l said you sacrifice a lot 

H: He came to Bir for some reason and I wish it's fulfilled 

Rinpoche: I  requested him』-Jane Huang’s Facebook

Analysis:

 Jane Huang thinks that Karmapa should learn from Rinpoche, so the idea of really wanting to change the Karmapa is entirely her wishful thinking.  Jane Huang deliberately fabricated false accusations and slandered Rinpoche.

Allegation 4.

『Jane Huang claims that Dzongsar Khyentse Rinpoche gave her to Karmapa』

“The H revealed that she was able to reach the Karmapa by the arrangement of Dzongsar Khyentse Rinpoche.” “Rinpoche hinted that she should visit the Karmapa.“」-Mirror Weekly 

The following are Correspondences between Jane Huang and Dzongsar Khyentse Rinpoche on January 26, 2015.

『H: Well the private audience is this morning. Should I go? I'm worried if I go he would be more upset. But if I don't go, it's not good because you have a record of no-show and next time will be difficult and I don't I think it's auspicious.

H: I hate to bother you with this. So Ridiculous! I can't do this everyday!

H: Can I go back to Taipei today?

Rinpoche: Why not

Rinpoche: Go to see him

H: This drives me crazy 

H: Ok l'll go』-Jane Huang’s Facebook 

 

 

Analysis:

 

The H mentioned "He" in the dialogue, according to the narration of the Dharma friend Ms Yang who met Karmapa with the H: 「In 2015, she seemed quite happy then, telling her friends that she had a boyfriend in Taiwan, and her boyfriend had been urging her to return to Taiwan, but she refused to change her ticket.  In order to reassure her boyfriend, she also asked Dharma friend to take a picture with her, saying that she would send the picture to her boyfriend. 」

 

H said to Rinpoche: " I'm worried if I go he would be more upset.", so this ‘he’ should mean her boyfriend, because her boyfriend has been pushing her to return to Taiwan.

 

 "Private interviews (with Karmapa) are arranged this morning, should I go?" The H herself made an appointment to meet Karmapa, but in turn accused it of being "H said through Dzongsar Khyentse Rinpoche's arrangement, She can get close to Karmapa.” She was completely deliberately slandering Rinpoche.  

 

From their conversation, H seems to be very confused. She doesn't know if she should return to Taipei or go to see Karmapa, so she asks Rinpoche.  Rinpoche answered her question "go to see him" , but H accused "Rinpoche hinted that she should visit the Karmapa." This is a false accusation.